Hotels in Fire Island

Best Fire Island Hotels

Enter your dates for prices and availability of the best hotels in Fire Island.

Swipe down to view more
Filter by:
Hotel Star Rating
≤2345
Guest Rating
Amazing 9+Great 8+Good 7+Pleasant 6+
Popular Filters for Fire Island
Breakfast includedIdeal locationWithin 4 kmHomes & aptsPool2 bedsTWA Flight 800 International Memorial and Gardens
Property Type
HotelGuest houseVacation home
Property facilities & services
PoolWi-Fi in public areasSmoking areaLuggage storagePets welcomeBarbecueGolf courseRestaurantBar

3 Best Hotels to Stay in Fire Island

Trip.com brings you a curated list of top accommodations in Fire Island, complete with reviews, price insights, and amenity highlights, making it easy to find the perfect place to stay.
Most Booked
Lowest price
Closest to downtown
Highest Rated
Grove Hotel Hotels in Fire Island
Grove Hotel Hotels in Fire IslandGrove Hotel Hotels in Fire IslandGrove Hotel Hotels in Fire IslandGrove Hotel Hotels in Fire IslandGrove Hotel Hotels in Fire IslandGrove Hotel Hotels in Fire Island
31
Hotels in Fire Island
Luggage storage
Wi-Fi in public areas
Beach volleyball
+4
When you stay at Grove Hotel in Sayville, you'll be on the boardwalk/promenade and 3.2 mi (5.1 km) from Ocean Beach. This hotel is within the region of Shorefront Park and Fire Island National Seashore. Enjoy recreational amenities such as a nightclub and a seasonal outdoor pool. This hotel also features complimentary wireless internet access, concierge services, and wedding services. Satisfy your appetite at The Ice Palace, a poolside café which features a bar/lounge and a pool view. Dining is also available at the coffee shop/cafe. Wrap up your day with a drink at the poolside bar. Featured amenities include express check-out, luggage storage, and ATM/banking services. A ferry terminal shuttle is available for a surcharge. Make yourself at home in one of the 63 air-conditioned rooms featuring Smart televisions. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and digital programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms feature showers, complimentary toiletries, and hair dryers. Conveniences include blackout drapes/curtains, housekeeping is provided on request, and irons/ironing boards can be requested.
Great
93 reviews
9.2/10
Check availability
Gatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in Obp, Sleeps 26, Steps from the Beach Hotels in Fire Island
Gatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in Obp, Sleeps 26, Steps from the Beach Hotels in Fire IslandGatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in Obp, Sleeps 26, Steps from the Beach Hotels in Fire IslandGatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in Obp, Sleeps 26, Steps from the Beach Hotels in Fire IslandGatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in Obp, Sleeps 26, Steps from the Beach Hotels in Fire IslandGatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in Obp, Sleeps 26, Steps from the Beach Hotels in Fire IslandGatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in Obp, Sleeps 26, Steps from the Beach Hotels in Fire Island
8
Hotels in Fire Island
Pool
Wi-Fi in public areas
One Of The Few Homes That Can Accommodate Your Entire Group of 16 or more!3 Day Minimum Booking, Reduced Rate For Weekly Bookings. Contact With Any Questions. • Heated Salt Water Pool Sunk In Deck - BRAND NEW HUGE 3 SEAT ADIRONDACK CHAIR• Sleeps up to 26• 5 Full Bathrooms• Newly Updated Kitchen Downstairs• 2 Hot Tubs• Large Adirondack Chairs Overlooking Ocean From 3rd DeckOne Of The Few Homes That Can Accommodate Your Entire Group of 24 or more!• Heated Salt Water Pool Sunk In Deck• HUGE 3 Seater Adirondack Chair Overlooking Pool• Sleeps up to 26• 5 Full Bathrooms• Newly Updated Kitchen Downstairs• 2 Hot Tubs• HUGE 2 Seater Adirondack Chairs Overlooking Ocean From 3rd DeckThis dual level home offers two units which connect seamlessly while allowing for private entrances. Each fully equipped with everything needed for your vacation while keeping your guests together. Upon arriving at the Ocean Bay Park ferry dock, take a quick 2-3 minute walk up to the ocean where you will find Gatsby's, with sprawling decks on each level of this home. Built into the main level deck is our newly added heated salt water plunge pool, outdoor dining table with seating for 12, enjoy a soak in one of the two hot tubs, head to the third deck you will feel like you’re on top of the island sitting in one of the two oversized cushioned Adirondack chairs, perfect way to start or end the day!When the evening is settling down you and your guests can enjoy one of two indoor living areas. Both indoor areas have generous seating equipped with smart TV’s and sound bars. The main level offering a wet bar area. One of the many favorite things guests noted about the living room is the double sliding glass doors letting in the fresh breeze and allowing for easy indoor/outdoor entertainment. The main level deck is where you can spend time in the salt water heated pool, perfect for a quick dip any time of day or head into one of the hot tubs. Our newly added 3 seater HUGE Adirondack Chair perfectly positioned to be apart of all the action without having to get wet. Rinse off the sand(please) in one of the two outdoor showers. Perfect for any size group with an outdoor dining table with seating for 12 and endless entertainment space. On the upper deck where you will find the second hot tub, additional entertainment space, outdoor couches overlooking stunning ocean views. Head up to the third deck where you can sit and relax day or night in one of the two GFCs (giant friggin chairs) Adirondack's.Be assured everyone will be comfortable in one of the seven bedrooms (house sleeps 26). Each bedroom has recessed lighting, window ACs, large closets, dresser space, and wifi throughout. No shortage of space when it comes time to get ready either. With 5 full bathrooms amongst the entire home, two of those with connecting outdoor showers, perfect for those who don’t want to miss a moment outside. No need to overpack or go home with dirty clothes either, washer and dryer units are also available.The top level is accessible by a spiral staircase with one king bed and two twins that can be arranged as a king size bed or kept separate and a full bathroom. The entire space bright with sunlight and breezes seeping in from the skylights throughout. Three additional bedrooms are located on the second level. Off of the kitchen offers a queen bed and two lofted twin beds, with a bathroom and connecting outdoor shower. Bedroom located towards the front of the house has a queen bed and sofa, third bedroom has a queen size bed. On the lower level you will find three additional bedrooms with natural light shining in from the oversized windows and two bathrooms, one with a connecting outdoor shower. The main level bedrooms are furnished with bunkbeds in each room. Queen size beds on the bottom and twin size on top. The first bedroom on the main level is an oversized double room with two bunk beds and sleeps 6. Whether you choose to cook in one of the two indoor kitchens or outside on one of two grills we want to make it as easy by providing the cooking utensils, supplies and propane. Kitchens include dishwasher (upstairs), electric stoves, microwaves and fridge/freezers with room for all your groceries. Upper level has seating at the kitchen table for 8, main level indoor table for 5 and main level deck can accommodate 12. Enjoy the day at the beach just a few steps away from the house making it simple to come back and take a dunk in the pool, grab lunch or cool off in the shade. OBP is less restrictive when it comes to enjoying the beach. Bring your cooler and your dog. (this isn't Ocean Beach)The nearby Village of Ocean Beach is a quick 10 minute bike ride or 20 minute walk for more dining, shopping & entertainment options.A welcome book will be provided at check in providing additional details about the home, places around town, other key points. Parking Note: There are no cars on Fire Island, ACCESSIBLE BY PASSENGER FERRY ONLY. We strongly recommend that you allow ample time during the peak season for parking. Please use the URL below regarding parking/pricing - fireislandferries .com - Ocean Bay Park, not Ocean BeachProperty Features:• Heated Salt Water Plunge Pool • 2-3 Minute Walk From Ferry, 2 Wagons Provided• Accommodations Up To 24 • Can entertain 50+ comfortably • Steps Away From The Beach• Two Hot Tubs• Two Jumbo Sized Adirondack Chairs• Two Outdoor Showers• Two Washer and Dryer's• Two Full Size Refrigerator/Freezers • Wi-Fi Throughout HomeHygiene and Cleaning: • 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper Per Bathroom• 1 Rolls of Paper Towels• Hand Soap, Dish Detergent, Dishwasher Tabs, Laundry Detergent, Body Soap, Shampoo & Conditioner• 1 Dish Sponge• 5 Garbage Bags Cooking Conveniences On Each Level:• Pots and Pans• Knives Sets• Utensils• 2 Propane Tanks (one for each grill)• Standard Brew Coffee Maker (Coffee Not Included)• K Cup Coffee Maker (Coffee Not Included)• Toaster • Large Serving Bowls Out and About:• Wagons• Beach chairs• Beach towels Technology and Streaming :• Wi-Fi • Smart TVs• Streaming Options Available With Personal Log In - Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime, AppleTV, RokuTV (included)Emergency Tools:• First Aid Kit • Flashlight • Fire ExtinguisherMAXIMUM 26 PERSON OCCUPANCY.MUST BE 30 YRS OR OLDER TO RENTSMOKING IS PERMITTED. PETS ALLOWED. WITH ADDITIONAL SECURITY.About pets:Pets allowed: dogs and cats (limit 4 total).About checkOut:Check out before 11:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About customRules:Community Quiet Hours - 9pm - 10am Daily Throw Trash Away And Close Gate Clean Dishes Take Photos Of Bikes And Wagons Upon Departure Please.About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking allowed: in designated areas.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 30.About events:Events allowed: family gatherings, birthday parties, weddings.Maximum event attendees: 75.
Check availability
Charming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower. Hotels in Fire Island
Charming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower. Hotels in Fire IslandCharming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower. Hotels in Fire IslandCharming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower. Hotels in Fire IslandCharming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower. Hotels in Fire IslandCharming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower. Hotels in Fire IslandCharming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower. Hotels in Fire Island
17
Hotels in Fire Island
Golf course
Snorkeling
Surfing
Relax in a charming Fire Island 3-br gem in Fair Harbor. Nestled on tranquil Walnut Walk, this house offers a soothing retreat for guests close to the ocean, the bay and ferry. The bedrooms are thoughtfully furnished with a queen bed, a twin bed, and a twin over full bunk bed, ensuring a comfortable stay for everyone. With 1.5 bathrooms, equipped with indoor and outdoor showers, A/C throughout, strong WiFi, washer/dryer, dishwasher, full indoor kitchen and outdoor grill, it's the perfect indoor/outdoor living environment. The living room space features a cozy pullout couch and relaxing armchairs perfect for kicking back. We look forward to welcoming you to our place, where enchantment and tranquility await.About pets:Pets allowed: less than 50 lbs per pet (limit one pet total).About checkOut:Check out before 11:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 25.About events:No events allowed.
Outstanding
4 reviews
10/10
Check availability
See More Hotels in Fire Island

Find your unique stays in Fire Island

Immerse yourself in the vibrant atmosphere of Fire Island with our handpicked accommodation options

FAQs About Fire Island Hotels

How do I book a hotel on Trip.com?

To book a hotel on Trip.com, simply enter your destination, travel dates, and the number of guests on the page. Then, browse through the available hotels and select the one you want to book. Follow the prompts to enter your payment information and complete the booking.

How do I get hotel deals on Trip.com?

There are several ways to find affordable hotels on Trip.com. You can narrow down your search results by filtering hotels according to your preferred price range, or you can sort the results by price to view the cheapest options first.

Where can I find hotel deals on Trip.com?

Trip.com offers a wide variety of hotel deals and promotions that are available throughout the year. You can easily find these special offers on our deals page. What's more, if you are a member of our loyalty program, you can sign in to your account and discover exclusive discounted rates at hotel list pages.

How can I get lower prices for hotels?

Sometimes booking hotels midweek is cheaper, but it also depends on the season.

How many hotels are listed on Trip.com?

You can find over 1.5 million hotels in more than 230 countries or regions on Trip.com. Haven't decided which hotel to book? Browse our site to get ideas!

Can I cancel or change my hotel bookings on Trip.com?

It depends on the hotel policy and date of cancellation. Please check the policy section of the related hotel pages. To cancel or change your bookings, sign in to your Trip.com account, go to "My Bookings", and follow the instructions.

How do I contact Trip.com customer support?

You can contact Trip.com's 24/7 customer support by visiting the Help Center on Trip.com and submitting a request. You can also contact us by phone or service chat, depending on your location.

Fire Island Hotels Info

Number of reviews
117
Total properties
3
Weekday Avg. Price
$328
Weekend Avg. Price
$327