Short and sweet: Whether you’ll love The Cove really comes down to what matters most to you. If five-star service (or even consistently four-star service) is important, this probably isn’t your place. But if you’re willing to overlook the laid-back approach to just about everything, particularly accuracy and timeliness, there’s a lot to love about this stunning resort. We certainly enjoyed our stay, although I wouldn’t spend the money on one of the villas. The Good: The property is absolutely gorgeous. Two pristine beaches with soft white sand, clear turquoise water, and gentle swimming areas. Paddleboarding, kayaking, and snorkeling equipment are included, and there’s never a battle for beach chairs. The landscaping is immaculate, the outdoor furniture is tasteful, and the entire property feels thoughtfully designed. There are lovely little touches, like complimentary sunscreen by the pool and a minibar stocked on arrival with a few drinks, including a small bottle of wine (though it wasn’t replenished). The resort was originally transformed from a foreclosed 1960s property by developer Sidney Torres and has since undergone another major renovation. The result is a beautiful, understated design with clean lines and uncluttered rooms. The beachfront rooms are particularly special. Being able to walk straight out of your room onto the sand is hard to beat. There are also wonderful places to sit and take in the views, including a porch outside the beachfront duplexes and a rocky sunset lookout where we spotted turtles. Breakfast is included, thankfully. The gym, yoga room, and spa are all lovely, and we thoroughly enjoyed our massage. The Bad: The service. By far. We started joking that every day brought a new surprise, usually something we’d ordered incorrectly prepared, forgotten, or delivered late. It’s almost impressive how consistently inconsistent the service is. Whether it’s inadequate training, poor management, or simply a different approach to hospitality, the result is the same: You cannot expect things to run smoothly. The food doesn’t help. Options are extremely limited, expensive, and repetitive. By day three, we’d had enough. The chef doesn’t seem particularly inspired, and the sushi, while perfectly edible, is nothing special. Then there are the fees. A $45 daily resort fee, plus an absurd $50 daily "service charge", and additional charges depending on your accommodation. It feels like nickel-and-diming at a property that’s already charging luxury prices. Especially when housekeeping itself is inconsistent. The infinity pool is beautiful but unheated, even in November. The ocean was warmer, and hardly anyone used the pool. We also paid $300 for round-trip airport transportation, only to be picked up in a dilapidated, hot, bug-infested van. The airport was so chaotic that we didn’t fully register how unacceptable it was until we’d arrived at the resort, just 20 minutes away. And finally, the hot water. As another review