Bay Lodging Resort ★★

Bayshore Resort at Put-in-Bay ★★

Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center ★★★

Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel ★★★

"Decided on the Anchor Inn on a recommendation from family. Exceeded expectations. Lovely property inside and out. Owners on site. Staff terrific. Had an intimate feel with a vibe of a larger luxury property. Rooms as nice as anywhere we’ve stayed. All accoutrements including two charging stations which shows the level of care. Then there’s the fabled breakfasts (included). Buffet spread with additional options of chef-prepared made to order breakfasts. Take Coops taxi from the ferry dock. Rent a golf cart (right across the street). Walk or ride to The GOAT or The Forge for elevated dining. Still casual enough and away from the dockside party fray."

Put in Bay Victory Station Hotel ★★

"Perfect little spot. less than 15 rooms and near downtown. Room was very clean and comfortable. staff was friendly. Will definitely return."

Edgewater Hotel and Suites ★★

Ahoy Inn Guesthouse ★★

"First let me state the host was very professional. Our room was immaculate . It was just under $200 for an unpopulated time of the week. It was a clean , quiet place to sleep. The issue is the only thing comfortable was the bed. The room had a tiny table and two uncomfortable decorative chairs. When we travel we spend more time in our room than just sleeping as do many. As a couples only Inn It should have two comfortable lounging chairs. We need a comfortable sitting area where we can eat meals in our room. There was no ice machine if we wanted to fill a small cooler. No complimentary breakfast. The little things really do matter for us. The neighboring Inn has a pastry and coffee bar. It’s the little things that keep us from returning. Would we return? Probably not. Not because of what it did have but what it didn’t. The website says exclusive rates for golf cart rentals for customers. $70 a day is standard rate all over. That’s just too high for something used very little in the rental window. If clean and quiet and close to downtown is all you need I recommend 100% . If you want more I’d consider another option."

Islander Inn ★★

Cozy Lakefront Middle Bass Retreat w/ Balcony ★★★