Surf and Sand, BW Signature Collection ★★★

"The location is a 2 minute walk to the beach and that's automatically a huge plus. The lobby smelled good but the room so so. The breakfast in the morning had good selections like fresh croissants and various packaged danishes. I didn't try the meat patties but they smelled horrendous. I like them generally but that smell was unusually bad. Service was good. For $140, I'm not sure if I'd stay again, but being it's basically on the beach it's ok I guess. For around $110 it'd be excellent value."

Hampton Inn & Suites Amelia Island-Historic Harbor Front ★★★

"Great location"

Hampton Inn Amelia Island at Fernandina Beach ★★

"Friendly, helpful staff. However it 2:15 we were told our room would be ready in 30 min and someone would call us. I did not receive a phone call & had to go back in one he. to check on the status of our room! Most of the food for breakfast. However the egg omelet did not have much taste & the bacon was greasy and so very thin! Bed and pillows were very comfortable. 5"

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Fernandina Beach Amelia Island by IHG ★★★

"I had a confirmed reservation at Holiday Inn Express, only to arrive and find the hotel completely closed. How does a company allow bookings for a property that isn’t even operating? When I contacted IHG Hotels & Resorts guest services, the experience got even worse. I was on hold for over 30 minutes, and the only “solution” offered was a hotel 40 minutes away. After traveling, this is completely unacceptable. This is beyond poor customer service—it’s a complete failure in basic operations and communication. IHG clearly does not value its customers’ time or trust. I will never book with them again."

Courtyard Amelia Island ★★★

"Overall, stay was good. Service at the front desk was mediocre at best."

Hoyt House Amelia Island ★★★

"Good location but the light is very dark in the evening, we couldn’t find the place , has to walked around to find the house, the poor was very dirty and not open to the public"

Amelia Hotel at the Beach ★★

Beachside Motel - Amelia Island ★★

"Was charged additional money after we checked out, was not notified."

Residence Inn Amelia Island ★★★

"My goodness this was the best room, service and breakfast I have had in quite a few years. I highly recommend this place for any reason. Setup to treat the guests like royalty."