Hotel Hochfirst ★★★

"In case of problems, help was quick and the breakfast was plentiful. At dinner, the lady told us that the table for 5 people was not for 2. But the day before, only 2 people had sat there. Today, only 1 person sat at the table for 5. We then went out to eat. Even as hotel guests, we weren't allowed to sit there. That's completely unacceptable."

Stuub Saig ★★★

"Check-in was quick and easy. The apartment was very clean. The kitchen had everything you could need. We'd gladly come back again!"

Maritim TitiseeHotel Titisee-Neustadt ★★★★

"The buffet offers a wide variety of choices, and the surrounding environment is beautiful and pleasant."

Coucou Hotel & Kuckucks-Stube (Titisee) ★★★

Jufa Hotel Schwarzwald ★★★

"The hotel is somewhat secluded near the edge of the forest in Saig. Quiet area. Very nice view. Half board is recommended as the nearest place to eat is a 10-minute walk away. The whole hotel is very old but will be renovated next winter. Very nice, large family room. All rooms can only be reached on foot. There is no elevator in the whole building. The rooms are all very old but clean. Bathrobes and towels as well as bathing shoes are available. The mattresses are rather hard and saggy. Very fine breakfast buffet. Everything is fresh. As there were very few guests, we were able to choose our evening meal from the menu. Everything was freshly cooked. Very tasty. The hotel's own playground inside and outside is rather meager. We missed a climbing playground like in other Jufa hotels. I hope that the playground will also be renovated during the renovation. The indoor pool and bowling alley are old but very nice and large. The ping pong table and football table are right next to the baby play area. Very nice staff. Always helpful and friendly."

Hotel Zum See, Titisee ★★★

"I loved the close proximity to Lake Titisee and the nostalgic furniture and facilities."

Hotel Saigerhöh Wellness Spa Golf Wandern über Dem Titisee ★★★★

"Hotel Saigerhöh – Mixed Feelings Our experience at Hotel Saigerhöh left us with mixed feelings, but I’ll try to describe it as accurately as possible. From the moment we arrived, things felt a bit off. The hotel is located at the end of a dead-end street, past a football field and a small construction site, surrounded by a bit of forest and perched on top of a hill. While the view over the valley from the hotel is indeed stunning, the building itself and its architectural style are rather uninspiring. Upon arrival, we were offered a welcome drink on a small, half-covered terrace—which also serves as the hotel's main smoking area. I understand that smoking is still relatively common in Germany, but we stayed there for no more than five minutes. When I told the reception staff I didn’t want to sit among smokers and asked if this was a usual practice, they seemed quite puzzled by the question. The hotel is large and spread across both sides of the street, connected by underground tunnels. We were given a short tour by a student worker, which was helpful. Our room was very spacious but extremely dated—the decor felt like it hadn’t changed since my grandmother’s time. It was hard to feel comfortable in it. The bathroom, however, had been recently renovated, so I suspect not all rooms have been updated yet. The wellness area is appreciated and has potential, but given the available space, more could certainly be done with it. In the evening, we went for a drink at the bar. Despite there being only three tables with guests, the bartender still managed to take over 30 minutes to serve us two drinks. We had dinner at the hotel only once (at €60 per person), and it was a real disappointment. While the dishes were nicely presented, the quality was far below what you’d expect from a 4-star hotel. The risotto, for instance, was unpleasant and far too salty. The fish was supposedly filleted but had not been cleaned properly—basic mistakes. This lack of quality was also noticeable in the service during both dinner and breakfast. The restaurant staff seemed uncoordinated and lost, with no clear supervision. At one point, our dessert was served to the wrong table, taken back to the kitchen, and then brought to us—by then, the sorbet was completely melted. That was the final straw for us. We decided to eat elsewhere for the remaining four nights. Interestingly, it seemed others had the same idea, as the hotel staff were actively encouraging guests at breakfast to reserve for dinner, even passing around a form to select your meal in advance. Breakfast itself was fairly extensive, but again, not up to 4-star standards. Food wasn’t fresh or properly presented—low-quality salmon, sour "freshly cut" fruit, etc. Also, finding a table on the terrace was a bit of a battle, as there weren’t enough of them. The only real highlights of the hotel were the wellness area and the view. Aside from that, I wouldn’t recommend this hotel, and I won’t be returning."

Hotel & Chalets Herrihof ★★★

"To get to this hotel, I got off the train and took a bus for about 40 minutes up a winding mountain road. The scenery and air were breathtaking. It's only a two- to three-minute walk from the bus stop, but the distance to the city center is a bit of a drawback. But if you're traveling to truly enjoy nature, it's fine. The building and rooms were quaint, but the bathroom facilities were surprisingly modern and convenient. It was wonderful. There was also a small terrace, but it was a bit inconvenient that there was no coffee pot, so you had to go down to the bar downstairs to make tea. The breakfast was excellent. The bread was delicious, the fruit fresh, and the perfectly soft-boiled eggs were unforgettable. They even brought the coffee pot to the table. There's no market nearby, so we couldn't buy food, so we had to buy it at the hotel restaurant. It feels a bit pricey for a hotel tucked away in the countryside, but I think it's worth it. The natural scenery is so beautiful that I'd stay in this town again next time, but I'd probably look for a slightly more affordable place to stay. But if money is no object, I recommend this hotel."

Tanneneck ★★